Wednesday, February 7, 2007

Earnest heemingway was a great writer but was he a great man?

Earnest hemingway was a great writer but was he a great man?

11 comments:

Jacob said...

No he was not a great man. For Bob's name people he commited suicide!!

laura said...

It depends how you define "great". Do you mean was he famous, was he talented, was he a good guy? etc.

Heat Seeker said...

I'm gonna side with Laura on this one!

Barzul

Jacob said...

Well i define greatr by wether or not a persons a good guy.

Chan said...

I don't know, I think that he was ok!!!

Anna-bug said...

I Don't know what to think about this guy, but i don't think he actually kept his word on things. i think this because one of his main themes in his book, was never to give up. and what did he do? he gave up by commiting cuicide! (sp)

Anonymous said...

I don't think he was a great man.(Don't tell Mrs. Koning that!)

Jacob said...

Chan how could you say that. i mean are you a fan of suicidals or something

laura said...

He commited suicide, but that doesn't mean he was bad, he just had problems. By good, I think of, was he caring, was he kind,did he care for anyone other than himself. I've heard of suicide described as the last act of thinking of yourself, or something like that, so I don't think that he really cared for anyone.

gollum said...

i don't think he was the "the model christian" but he lived through a hard time. i think the war scared him for life.

Jacob said...

Not scared Bob. Scarred.